Vegan No-bake Chocolate Pumpkin Pie

It’s the day before Thanksgiving and you know what that means, time to make the pumpkin pie and stick it in the fridge so you don’t have to think about it along with the million other things you have to think about cooking tomorrow.  The great thing about this recipe is that it requires no bake time, so even if you put it off until the last minute, it’s quick and won’t take up any of your precious oven space.

Be forewarned this is not your Grandmother’s pumpkin pie.  This is a decadent, melt in your mouth pumpkin pie with a crumbly cookie crust.  The rich chocolate flavor is the first thing you notice.  It doesn’t strike you immediately that it’s a pumpkin pie until the smooth consistency melts in your mouth and hints of cinnamon, ginger and cloves pop up and is just lovely.

Cookie Crust
16 Oreos, or more natural alternative like Newman’s Organic Chocolate Cream Cookies
1/3 c vegan margarine
1/3 c AP flour

1/2 c water
1 tsp agar agar
1 c sugar
1 tsp cinnamon
1/2 tsp ginger
1/4 tsp ground cloves
1 1/2 cans of pumpkin (about 22 oz)
1 c dark chocolate chunks or chips

Break up the cookies into the smallest bits you can.  Then add in the vegan margarine, which will leave it gooey and soft, adding the flour will help to give it a thicker consistency that will hold it together.  When completely blended put in the refrigerator to harden.

I found the only way to work with the crust was when it’s cold.  Once it hardened in the fridge I began pushing it into a greased pie pan with the bottom of a glass.  If it began to melt and stick to the glass I would return it to the fridge to harden again.  In the end you should have a pie pan evenly coated with a cookie crumb crust.

While you are preparing the crust, add the agar agar to the water and let sit to make sure it is fully dissolved.  Agar agar is a gelatin substitute derived from seaweed.  It will help the pie become firm without baking.

After the crust is finished, start preparing the filling by heating up the agar agar solution, sugar and spices in a large sauce pan until they begin to bubble.  reduce the heat to prevent it from bubbling up too much.

Add the pumpkin and let cook for about a minute.

Then turn off the heat and add the chocolate.  It will melt completely in since the mixture is still very hot, but you don’t want to cook the chocolate or it will ruin its texture.

Pour into the pie crust and smooth the top.  Garnish if you’d like with cookie crumbs, a cookie in the center, chocolate shavings, or if you’d like you can melt the chocolate separately and swirl it in with the filling.

Refrigerate for a couple hours before serving.  It will become firm upon cooling, even more so than is pictured above, since I was a bit impatient to slice it up.

Yields 12 servings


Would go great with:



34 Responses to “Vegan No-bake Chocolate Pumpkin Pie”
  1. Justin says:

    I tasted the pie you see in the pictures, and I can say without any exaggeration that it was honestly the best pie I’ve ever tasted in my entire life.

  2. jacqueline says:

    thanks justin!

  3. Kevin says:

    A chocolate pumpkin pie sounds so good!

  4. Michael Pasternak says:

    What is “earth Balance”?

  5. banderson says:

    and what is agar agar?

    this looks delicious and sounds exactly like how i’d like to end thanksgiving this year!

  6. Pele says:

    I replaced cornstarch for the agar with good results. I also upped the amount of spice in the filling– I added ground cardamon, black peppercorns and red chili pepper. Thanks for the splendid idea.

  7. Ruth Hirsch says:

    This is the pie.
    Why would you make anything else? It’s easy. It’s delicious. And it’s something you can be proud to share with your family because it won’t slowly kill them.
    Thanks for the great recipe. It was just in time.

  8. VEGirl says:

    Wow, what a great idea! I am gluten-intolerant so I don’t have oreos, but I bet the filling would just be good on it’s own…..


  9. Tessa says:

    Mmm this looks so good! How come I haven’t made it yet?? Since I missed making it for Thanksgiving, maybe it’s perfect for Christmas dinner!

  10. banderson says:

    made this last year and we LOVED it. so much that i’d like to make it again this year. still have agar agar. now i’m wondering if i can cut the sugar by half, using 1/2 cup rather than a whole. any insight?

  11. Sonia says:

    Hi, I’m new at cooking and I was wondering if it’s safe to eat the crust even if the flour is not cooked? Sorry if this seems like a dumb question.

    Thanks for the recipe, btw!

  12. Sonia says:

    That’s good to know! I was also curious to know what do you do with the cookies’ filling cream? Do you toss it or can I use it as the butter substitute for the crust? If not, can I use it for the filling with pumpkin?

    Thanks again!

  13. jessie says:

    When you mean agar agar, do you mean flakes or powder…?


Check out what others are saying...
  1. […] no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie […]

  2. […] prepared the No Bake Vegan Chocolate Pumpkin Pie from Sweet Beat and Green Bean today.  Holy YUM!  I spread some left over filling on a piece of […]

  3. […] Sweet Beet and Green Bean’s Vegan No-Bake Chocolate Pumpkin Pie: I used Newman-Os (no hydrogenated oils and YUM), Ghiradelli bittersweet chocolate, and Farmer’s Market Organic Pumpkin. […]

  4. […] chocolate pumpkin pie Image by sweetbeetandgreenbean for the recipe:… […]

  5. Easy Vegan Recipe for Holiday Dessert…

    It’s an easy, you can make it ahead of time, and it’s got chocolate.  Sound like a perfect holiday dessert?  It is. I’ve made this no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie from the Sweet Beet and Green Bean blog several times and I love it. The …

  6. […] no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie from sweet beat and green bean (photo below) […]

  7. […] no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie Image by sweetbeetandgreenbean for the recipe:… […]

  8. […] no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie for the recipe:… […]

  9. […] chocolate pumpkin pie, prepared to be chilled Image by sweetbeetandgreenbean for the recipe:… […]

  10. […] No-Bake Chocolate Pumpkin Pie from Sweet Beet and Green Bean No-bake, chocolate, and pumpkin. Those three sound pretty good to me! Looks all creamy and delicious too. This is my first visit to this blog and with a recipe like this, will not be my last. […]

  11. […] chocolate pumpkin pie Image by sweetbeetandgreenbean for the recipe:… This entry was posted in Recipes and tagged BAKE, Cool, images, Recipes. Bookmark the permalink. […]

  12. […] no-bake chocolate pumpkin pie Image by sweetbeetandgreenbean for the recipe:… […]

Leave A Comment